Jan 8, 2022
The UnDiscussed Market Moves
Well another day has begun and it’s very near the end of 2021 with just two more days before the calendar rolls over. It’s yet again, lightly raining outside with a grey cloudy mist hovering over the moderately warm Atlanta sky. I’ve just poured a cup of coffee and completed some standard weekday preliminaries which often include waking up to the light sounds of public radio around 7:45, then reaching for my phone to scan a few items of importance before gently springing from the cocoon of sheets in my bed.
One of the first items of interest that I observe nearly each day are the financial headlines. The source that I turn to for this cursory overview each morning is CNBC’s website where the banner of their homepage displays the stock market futures activity. The emphasis of this market indicator is rather obscure and it’s a frequently mentioned yet rarely discussed determinant of overall stock prices. I don’t pretend to have a great deal of technical knowledge about the interoperations of the futures but I feel that my general assessment and applicability of their behavior is worth giving some discussion here.
Futures are types of products that were created many decades ago primarily for use in the agricultural commerce trade. The idea was that the archaic days of simply brining all of your harvest, livestock, or precious commodities to a marketplace and orchestrating a sale was not a modern enough method for exchanging bulk goods. Thus contracts were created which both the procurers and buyers of these goods would enter into based upon prespecified terms which included such things as quantity, price, quality and other contingencies. So a farmer with thousands of bushels of corn for example, could negotiate a future sale of his crop to a Whiskey distiller months, even years in advance in order to eliminate uncertainties in their business. It’s no wonder that many of these contracts originated out of organizations based in and around Chicago such as the Mercantile Exchange and Board of Trade given the Midwest’s proclivity for agricultural dominance.
Surely the dynamic and modernization of commerce was greatly enhanced by contractual agreements for all sorts of items including cotton, cattle, produce, metals, fuel and other perishables. Yet, as these contracts became standardized, they became tradeable so as parties could enter and exit their commitments by taking a counter position of the future contractual agreement. The prices of these instruments fluctuated based on supply/demand often determined by product quality, macro-micro economic and industry wide conditions.
Then somewhere along the way, similar futures types of commitments became available for currencies and then on financial products such as shares of stock and the overall performance of the blue chip indices including the Dow Jones, S&P and later the Nasdaq.
Now fast forward to year 2021 and the frequently mentioned, yet often unexplained preponderance of stock market futures activity is a major indicator for how individual stocks are likely to perform. NPR for example every morning well before the stock market officially opens for regularly trading at 9:30am, will provide a comment for the Dow, S&P500 and Nasdaq futures.
Any given morning, the price of these seemingly transparent major indices of measured collective performance can change from the day before due to the futures market. Frankly, its a seemingly unusual notion to think that the Dow, S&P, and Nasdaq can be priced substantially different than the day before due to the overnight and extended hours futures contracts activity. But this phenomena becomes even more unsettling when you begin to understand how this price action affects the overall pricing behavior and the enormous impact that it can have on individual stock prices.
Lets think again at the three major US stock indices mention above. What is their purpose? Well the seemingly honest, straightforward answer is that they are intended to be an objectively calculated pricing measure of all the constituent companies listed within. For the Dow, the index is supposed to represent a measure of the underlying thirty major company’s stock prices. The S&P is intended to be much more broad as it consists of 500 leading company’s stock prices across many different sectors of the US economy. The Nasdaq claims to represent a calculation of the aggregate stock prices for some of the one hundred biggest and best technology companies.
For a novice, the math used in determining each of these three indices wouldn’t appear to be too complex as one might assume that you simply take the total summation of all the constituent company stock prices affected by their daily changes and viola you have an index value. However, as I was first told during my Investments 101 class in college, these indices have different calculation methods that are adjusted over time to take into account a number of different elements such as stock splits, dividend payouts, subsequent inclusion/exclusion of the constituent companies. Of further importance, the weighting for each of the constituent companies is not simply what many might expect. Index values aren’t simply an equal summation of all the prices added together but rather a less transparent measure that has become more and more complex over time.
The Dow was originally supposed to be rather easy to calculate, as it claims to be a ‘price weighted series’ but as years of adjustments have been made it now includes a divisor that surely is like something of a messy physics equation. The other two indices are ‘market-weighted series’, meaning that their values are intended to be derived not so much by price but by the market capitalization of each constituent company i.e. (Share Price X the # of shares outstanding).
As time has gone on, the complexities have only compounded. Given that none of these are equally weighted measures of performance, they are susceptible to skewed bias of market capitalization enlargement by any one or small grouping of companies. So as the larger valued of these constituent companies get bigger, it has a larger impact on the movements of the index overall. For example Apple( $AAPL) is by far the most valued company, at approximately $3trillion, on the US stock market and it’s berth in valuation holds a significant impact on all three indices. Microsoft is the 2nd most valuable company and it too holds huge sway on index prices. These are then followed by a handful of other companies whose total market capitalization is in excess of $1trillion including Amazon, Google, and Tesla.
Only five companies currently hold valuations in excess of $1 trillion. A few close notables also include Facebook and Nvidia but all of the next largest US listed companies pale in comparison to the $1trillion mark. Astoundingly Apple’s $3.1trillion market capitalization increased approximately 300% in only a few years, caused by a combination of it’s strong financial performance, a stock split in 2020, broad investor interest but also by the affects of being the largest price influencing company of the US stock market. When Apple moves as too Microsoft, Amazon, Google, and Tesla, it inherently has an outsized impact on the indices in which they are included. The hundreds of others companies in the market also have an impact on index levels but to much smaller degree.
But wait that’s not all, remember how we talked about the futures? Well that is another market, inextricably linked nonetheless to the US common equity market. But it trades differently and these futures contract values have increasingly held major sway for the overall performance of US stocks. The futures contracts trade 23 hours a day, six days a week. They open at 6pm on Sunday evening, run nearly continuously until Friday at 5:15pm with two short maintenance breaks occurring each day from 4:15-4:30pm and 5:30-6pm.
So nearly around the clock, investors, traders, big money speculators can transact on the value of these three major US indexes via the futures. The contracts that are traded are extremely liquid and they really signify little other than where the value of these indexes are likely to be in some future dated time. Thus because of their easy transactability, low barriers to entry among traders and increasingly profit motivated speculation they have become primarily instruments of short-term price movement. Any contractual obligation to purchase or deliver the underlying basket of index securities in the future can immediately be negated by closing one’s speculative position through a sell or a cover if one enters a short position.
Thus a market has been created and grown based upon groups of individuals who have little to no desire in upholding their ultimate contractual obligation of transacting the actual underlying company stock. Rather, they are buying, selling, shorting, and covering the various speculative price action of the indexes. As these financial futures are traded throughout the day and overnight, their price movements directly determine the stated value of the indexes aswell, despite the underlying company’s regular hours of 9:30-4pm.
So when I wake up as part of my morning routine as mentioned earlier and check the top of CNBC’s website from my phone, I aim to find how the overnight and wee hour participants affected the prices of these indexes. Wherever the ‘front’ futures contracts are trading at around 9:28am, is where indexes are set to open to begin the regular-hours stock trading each day. So again, indices that are supposed to objectively measure the price summation of the nation’s leading companies in hopes of providing a general assessment of overall market activity are actually being dictated by some other wildly speculative force. It has in fact become such a concern that for many months, it is the futures prices that’ve had the largest impact on stock prices and in ever more distorting ways.
The action of the index futures prices is largely dictated by news events and ongoing developments in micro-economic conditions across a whole range of different topics. The volatility of these contracts are very sensitive to ‘headline risk’ such as former president Trump’s trade war with China, the ongoing Federal Reserve commentary, global developments, disruptions, Covid 19 status, company news, marco-financial projections and so on.
It has increasingly become more common to see huge swings in the overnight futures which then often dictate the price behavior for many of the companies within the overall stock market. If for example, the Dow Jones index, Nasdaq and S&P 500 futures are indicated up by 300points, 150points and 45points respectively, it’s generally an optimistic signal that stocks are likely poised for an upward moving start to the day. It has the effect of more or less setting the tone for equity prices.
Consequently, if the index’s open higher, many of the individual stocks will open higher as well. When that happens several things may actually occur, either the prices retrace back to around where they closed at the previous afternoon or they continue to move higher.
Some company’s stocks will find themselves highly correlated and behaving similar to indexes performance throughout the day. While other stocks will show low correlation and behave idiosyncratically.
On the contrary, if some troubling news appears imminent and overnight futures are selling lower, then the indexes open lower while so too do many of the individual stock prices. It can quickly become a cascading effect where lower prices at the open will beget more selling, which triggers stop loss orders and algorithmic trading machines send prices lower. This was the alarming phenomena that occurred during February/March of 2020 upon the early days of Covid19. The market then experienced numerous days when the futures were pricing the index levels to open by figures as much as negative 1000points for the Dow, 500points for the Nasdaq and 100points for the S&P.
In fact on many occasions, the market circuit breaker halts were triggered by such premarket price movements that delayed openings until 9:45-10:00 so that the exchanges could try and mitigate the harm. During many of those atrocious price destroying days, the volume of buyers and sellers looked to have nearly evaporated and prices just continued to move lower.
Then a similar opposite effect began to occur. The market was experiencing enormously higher index prices at the open which in turn was lifting prices for many individual securities. Their were circuit breaker halts as index pricing was in excess of 10% from their previous day’s close.
In theory one might be inclined to wonder, well how can a stock price open at such a drastically different level than where it closed the night before? By nature a stock price is entirely supposed to be a measure of what the last transacted value was for a certain security between a buyer and seller. Yet prices were drastically moving in expeditious fashion and in scantly justifiable ways. When prices take on such a sporadic course, it’s somewhat analogous to a heart skipping its beat only to begin functioning again at some newfound rhythm.
Not simply to lament on the negative of downward prices but the move higher in the futures, indexes and underlying stocks that transpired for many months during the bullish great recovery of 2020-21 was astoundingly strong. One medium term affect was that market capitalizations for many companies soon escalated well beyond what they had ever seen before, despite being in the midst of a health pandemic.
I feel that the question of how does this happen, has in part been addressed by explaining individual stock price gyrations in terms of their relation to the indexes which are in turn to a large degree influenced by the financial futures market.
One big remaining question though, is why does this happen? Well, I am of the strong belief, that it is to protect the interest and maximize profitability of the so-called middlemen or market makers and the exchanges who are required to take the opposite sides of a trade. Liquidity in the US financial markets often abundant because there are these intermediaries who are supposed to help smooth the function of exchange by directing orders between parties and at times receiving the spread between the bid and ask price of a given security.
This critical type of involvement between buyers and sellers is believed to be done on either a principal or an agency basis.
On a principal basis, the market maker simply facilitates the transaction of a buy or sell between two interested parties and thus is compensated by a commission in terms of the bid/ask price spread. On an agency basis however, the market makers who often are employees of the exchanges, big financial firms and very often even your own online broke may take an ownership stake for their own inventory only to sell it or buy it to market participants at some later time. This second example is what has often been criticized in the payment for order flow conundrum.
So in an erratic price environment where prices experience large fluctuations from one afternoon to the next morning, these ‘intermediaries’ can eliminate unfavorable terms for themselves by dropping the prices for which they are required to buy shares of stock faster than the market participants are able to sell, i.e. skipped heartbeat. If the institutional powers that help facilitate the functioning of the market perceive a significant sell off, they will do all in their power to preemptively drop the market lower overnight so that they aren’t forced to start buying stock from investors at the previous day’s closing prices. If market makers are to begin absorbing inventory, they’d much rather do so at lower prices knowing that they can resell it either marginally lower or at higher prices sometime in the future.
The opposite is also true. If the stock market and many of it’s corresponding securities opens higher from one day to the next, the price that these market makers are likely to receive has already been adjusted significantly higher. This appears to often be the case where the overall market tanks one day, only to open significantly higher the next. Of course, these scenarios also play out favorably for the astute investors or traders who are able to ‘time the market’, by buying and selling based upon this erratic price behavior.
While their certainly is a lot more to uncover and discuss regarding the rarely considered realities of the stock market, I feel that this is a good entry point to providing some clarity into the actual and often nefarious on-goings of the market.

